KPM

IRA

Are You a Trader or Investor? For Tax Purposes, You Need to Know.

Do you have significant investment-related expenses, including the cost of subscriptions to financial services, home office expenses, and clerical costs? Under current tax law, these expenses are not deductible through 2025 if they are considered investment expenses for the production of income. However, they are deductible if they are considered trade or business expenses.

For years before 2018, production-of-income expenses were deductible, but they were included in miscellaneous itemized deductions, which were subject to a 2%-of-adjusted-gross-income floor. (These rules are scheduled to return after 2025). If you do a significant amount of trading, you should know which category your investment expenses fall into, because qualifying for trade or business expense treatment is more advantageous now.

To deduct your investment-related expenses as business expenses, you must be engaged in a trade or business. The U.S. Supreme Court held many years ago that an individual taxpayer is not engaged in a trade or business merely because the individual manages their own securities investments — regardless of the amount or the extent of the work required.

Trader vs. Investor
However, if you can show that your investment activities rise to the level of carrying on a trade or business, you may be considered a trader, who is engaged in a trade or business, rather than an investor, who is not. As a trader, you are entitled to deduct your investment-related expenses as business expenses. A trader also is entitled to deduct home office expenses if the home office is used exclusively on a regular basis as the trader’s principal place of business. An investor, on the other hand, is not entitled to home office deductions since the investment activities are not a trade or business.

Since the Supreme Court decision, there has been extensive litigation on the issue of whether a taxpayer is a trader or investor. The U.S. Tax Court has developed a two-part test that must be satisfied for a taxpayer to be a trader. Under this test, a taxpayer’s investment activities are considered a trade or business only where both of the following are true:

1. The taxpayer’s trading is substantial (in other words, sporadic trading is not considered a trade or business).

2. The taxpayer seeks to profit from short-term market swings, rather than from long-term holding of investments.

Profit in the Short Term
So, the fact that a taxpayer’s investment activities are regular, extensive, and continuous is not in itself sufficient for determining that a taxpayer is a trader. To be considered a trader, you must show that you buy and sell securities with reasonable frequency in an effort to profit on a short-term basis. In one case, a taxpayer who made more than 1,000 trades a year with trading activities averaging about $16 million annually was held to be an investor rather than a trader because the holding periods for stocks sold averaged about one year.

Contact us if you have questions or would like to determine whether you are an investor or a trader for tax purposes.

Related Articles

Talk with the pros

Our CPAs and advisors are a great resource if you’re ready to learn even more.