The amount of money your non-profit raises in fundraising campaigns is meaningful but so is how efficiently you are able to raise it. Such costs can be measured using two metrics: cost ratio and return on investment (ROI) – each are discussed below.
Find a formula
These two metrics can be used to evaluate both fundraising activities and individual fundraising events or campaigns. Concentrating not only on the big picture, but also on specific fundraising activities, allows your organization to identify stronger strategies to use more frequently and weaker ones to consider improving or ending. Ultimately, the goal is to determine which activities generate the highest return.
Cost ratio (also known as cost-per-dollar, which is fundraising expense / fundraising revenue) focuses on the expense of fundraising, while ROI focuses on the returns. The formula for ROI uses the same inputs as cost ratio but flips them; the fundraising expense, of course, is the ‘investment’ ROI is referring to, and is calculated as:
ROI = Fundraising revenue / Investment in fundraising
Some non-profits use gross revenues in the ROI formula. However, many others use net revenues (revenues minus the related expenses). Either option is acceptable, but you must be consistent and measure revenues the same way for every year and campaign. After all, these metrics are meaningful only when you compare fundraising activities or trends from one year to prior years.
Fundraising expense data should include the direct costs of the initial effort, as well as later activities. Initial costs might include an investment in online advertising or a phone campaign, while subsequent costs might relate to maintaining that relationship, such as a renewal mailing.
As for indirect and overhead costs, exclude those that you would incur with or without the monitored activity (such as website or donor database costs). In addition, make sure they are excluded from every campaign metric. For both costs and revenues, use rolling averages that cover three to five years. This will reduce the effect of ‘one-offs,’ whether in the form of a significant donation or an economic downturn. You also will avoid penalizing fundraising activities, such as a major gift campaign, that require some time to show results.
Calculating fundraising metrics will help you make better decisions when it comes to allocating limited resources. Also keep in mind that ROI can vary greatly by activity, and a lower ROI does not necessarily mean you should cut the activity. Contact us for more information.